JOURNAL · REFLECTION 02
Beyond the Metrics: Rethinking Legitimacy in Social Enterprise from the Ground in Nairobi
My recent visit to Kiseki Limited in Nairobi offered more than insights into waste management or circular economy practices. It raised deeper questions about how the global development and social enterprise ecosystem frames, measures, and legitimizes impact - especially when that judgment comes from outside the realities in which such enterprises operate.
Kiseki Limited works with discarded glass bottles, transforming what many would consider waste into new products through recycling and upcycling processes. On the surface, this aligns closely with ideas promoted in global sustainability discourse, particularly the concept of the Circular Economy. The circular economy promotes reducing waste and extending the lifecycle of materials, an approach increasingly discussed in global environmental policy and business strategy (Geissdoerfer et al., 2017). However, witnessing Kiseki's work on the ground revealed how differently these concepts exist in practice compared to how they are often discussed in academic papers or strategic presentations.
In many Western contexts, social enterprises are expected to demonstrate legitimacy through structured narratives such as impact reporting, logic models, and a clearly articulated theory of change. These frameworks aim to demonstrate accountability and measurable outcomes (Nicholls, 2010). While useful, they also reveal an imbalance of perspective. They are frequently designed and evaluated by institutions far removed from the environments in which the work actually happens.
At Kiseki, the reality looked different. Employees and management were not discussing formal impact frameworks or donor reporting metrics. Their focus was on sustaining operations, managing resources efficiently, and ensuring that the enterprise could continue providing livelihoods. Waste management work requires persistence and resilience. The process of collecting, cleaning, sorting, and repurposing glass bottles is labour intensive, yet it also represents a practical example of environmental sustainability and local economic participation.
The people working there had aspirations that extended beyond the narrow indicators typically used in social enterprise evaluations. Some hoped to support their families through stable income, while others were motivated by the opportunity to learn skills and contribute to environmental protection. These ambitions rarely appear in formal impact dashboards, yet they are arguably among the most meaningful indicators of social value creation.
This observation raises a broader issue within the global discourse on social entrepreneurship. The concept of Social Entrepreneurship is frequently defined as the pursuit of innovative solutions to social problems through entrepreneurial methods (Dees, 1998). However, the frameworks used to analyse these enterprises are often developed in academic or institutional environments that are geographically and socially distant from the communities being studied.
Many professionals migrate from regions such as Latin America, Africa, and South Asia to build careers in global financial centres or academic hubs. From these spaces, research and evaluation frameworks are developed to measure impact in the so-called developing world. While these perspectives can contribute valuable insights, they can also unintentionally reproduce a "top-down" approach to understanding social impact.
Scholars have long argued that development narratives sometimes reflect a tendency to frame communities in the Global South through an external lens rather than through locally grounded experiences (Escobar, 2011). Observing Kiseki's work reinforced this concern. The workers engaged in the recycling process were not thinking about how their activities might appear in an international impact report. Their attention was directed toward practical concerns: securing materials, maintaining equipment, and ensuring consistent income.
This experience also revived a recurring question: what truly defines a social enterprise?
Is it an organisation operating within economically disadvantaged contexts?
Is it defined by financial performance or profitability?
Or is revenue simply a by-product of a deeper mission to generate social and environmental value?
Equally important is the question of who gets to judge that impact. In the global development ecosystem, legitimacy is often linked to external funding sources, philanthropic partnerships, or impact investment. Enterprises that receive grants from large corporations or global foundations may gain credibility through association with well-known institutions.
However, this dynamic can obscure the legitimacy of enterprises that grow through self-funded operations. Many small organisations in emerging economies build their impact gradually through earned revenue and community engagement. They experiment, adapt, and expand without relying on large philanthropic grants or corporate sponsorship.
Some scholars have also highlighted the complex historical context in which contemporary philanthropy operates. Wealth accumulation in many industrialised countries has historically been linked to resource extraction and economic structures shaped during colonial and post-colonial periods (Moyo, 2009). Today, a portion of this wealth returns to developing regions through aid, charity, and corporate social responsibility initiatives.
While such funding can support meaningful projects, it can also shape the narrative of who is recognised as a legitimate social entrepreneur. Organisations backed by major donors often possess the resources to produce detailed impact reports and evaluation frameworks, reinforcing their visibility within the sector.
Standing in Kiseki's workspace, watching bottles being sorted and transformed into new products, the legitimacy of their work felt immediate and tangible. The environmental benefits were visible, and the livelihoods created were real. The circular economy was not an abstract sustainability concept - it was a daily practice embedded in routine labour and local knowledge.
Yet enterprises like Kiseki may rarely appear in global social enterprise case studies because they lack the capacity to generate the polished documentation often required by international stakeholders.
This disconnect highlights a broader tension within the social enterprise ecosystem. Academic research, impact evaluation frameworks, and development analytics will undoubtedly continue to evolve. At the same time, workers and entrepreneurs in places like Nairobi will continue their daily efforts to create livelihoods and environmental solutions - often without recognition from the systems designed to measure them.
The visit to Kiseki did not provide definitive answers. Instead, it reinforced the complexity of defining social impact across different economic and cultural contexts.
Perhaps legitimacy should not always be determined solely by those with the most sophisticated reporting tools or institutional authority. Perhaps it should also be recognised in the persistence of people who transform waste into opportunity, sustain their communities through practical innovation, and embody the principles of sustainability long before they become global policy frameworks.
In the end, the question remains open: who truly has the right to measure impact - and who is actually living it?
“Legitimacy lives in persistence, not only in reports.”
References
- Dees, J. G. (1998). The meaning of social entrepreneurship. Stanford University Graduate School of Business.
- Escobar, A. (2011). Encountering development: The making and unmaking of the Third World. Princeton University Press.
- Geissdoerfer, M., Savaget, P., Bocken, N. M. P., & Hultink, E. J. (2017). The circular economy: A new sustainability paradigm? Journal of Cleaner Production, 143, 757–768. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.12.048
- Moyo, D. (2009). Dead aid: Why aid is not working and how there is another way for Africa. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- Nicholls, A. (2010). The legitimacy of social entrepreneurship: Reflexive isomorphism in a pre-paradigmatic field. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 34(4), 611–633. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6520.2010.00397.x